Caution: Spoilers ahead.

Director Rian Johnson knows that some of the decisions he made in Star Wars: The Last Jedi have polarized fans. An opinionated Star Wars fan himself, Johnson has mostly acknowledged the haters with Yoda-like zen. But apparently, he’s grown weary of one particular critique: that Luke’s use of his Force powers in the climactic scene falls outside of a Jedi’s established abilities. On Friday, the writer-director clapped back with a Twitter thread of photos, using a Star Wars reference from his own bookshelf to prove that he did his Jedi homework.

In one of the final scenes of The Last Jedi, Luke Skywalker shows up on the isolated planet Crait to engage in battle with his estranged nephew, First Order leader Kylo Ren. Unbeknownst at first to Kylo Ren (and the audience), Luke is not actually present; he’s deep in meditation on the island of Ahch-To, and is projecting his image using the Force. His gambit provides a necessary diversion for the Resistance to make a getaway. It also uses the last of Luke’s strength; once his projected image vanishes from Crait, he fades out of existence on Ahch-To.

Earlier on, the film introduced the idea that Jedi could project themselves by establishing a Force connection between Rey and Kylo Ren, who could see and feel one another’s presence from separate locations. Still, countless internet debates have raged about whether Johnson was overstepping the bounds of Force mythology. Here, in tweets, is Johnson’s response.

12h

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
👀

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/3IvzVcIBji

11:00 AM – Jan 19, 2018
View image on Twitter
127 127 Replies 1,968 1,968 Retweets 15,264 15,264 likes
Twitter Ads info and privacy
12h

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
Replying to @rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/3IvzVcIBji

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/IEe2wdLp4l

11:00 AM – Jan 19, 2018
View image on Twitter
147 147 Replies 2,315 2,315 Retweets 13,803 13,803 likes
Twitter Ads info and privacy
12h

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
Replying to @rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/IEe2wdLp4l

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/cxJ6y1i8nu

11:00 AM – Jan 19, 2018
View image on Twitter
159 159 Replies 2,928 2,928 Retweets 15,421 15,421 likes
Twitter Ads info and privacy
12h

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
Replying to @rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/cxJ6y1i8nu

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/L3Ngau6bxH

11:01 AM – Jan 19, 2018
View image on Twitter
143 143 Replies 2,864 2,864 Retweets 15,687 15,687 likes
Twitter Ads info and privacy
12h

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
Replying to @rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/L3Ngau6bxH

Rian Johnson

@rianjohnson
pic.twitter.com/ErfkfHmWNq

11:01 AM – Jan 19, 2018
View image on Twitter
843 843 Replies 7,035 7,035 Retweets 30,536 30,536 likes
Twitter Ads info and privacy
To sum up: The ability for a Jedi to “create a short-lived duplicate of himself or herself” is clearly outlined in the Advanced Force Techniques section of the ancient Jedi manual The Jedi Path. Granted, The Jedi Path was actually written and published in fall 2010 — but that still means that Luke’s astral projection was established, in canon, years before Johnson began working on The Last Jedi.

Naturally, Johnson closed the conversation with the classic “Homer retreating into the bushes” GIF.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.